Disciplinary updates - November 2012

  • Thursday,
Red card Red card
prev next
The recent charges and hearing outcomes

Friday 30 November

John Obi Mikel, Chelsea FC
Chelsea v Manchester United
Premier League, 28 October 2012
FA Rule E3 - use of threatening and/or abusive and/or insulting words and/or behaviour

Mikel has admitted the charge and requested a personal hearing

Bristol Rovers FC
Bristol Rovers v Bradford City
Football League 2, 24 November 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players and/or officials conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative behaviour

Bristol Rovers FC has admitted the charge and requested a paper hearing

Bradford City FC
Bristol Rovers v Bradford City
Football League 2, 24 November 2012
FA Rule E20(a) - failure to ensure that its players and/or officials conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative behaviour

Bradford City FC has admitted the charge and requested a personal hearing

Joe Colbeck, Grimsby Town FC
Twitter comments
Four breaches of FA Rule E3 – comments posted on Twitter account which were improper and/or brought the game into disrepute. Further alleged that these breaches included a reference to a person’s or persons’ disability and/or sexual orientation within the meaning of FA Rule E3(2)
Colbeck admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Colbeck was fined £1,500 and warned as to his future conduct

Click here for the full written reasons of the case

Sam Whiting, AFC Wimbledon
Dartford Whites Youth v AFC Wimbledon Youth
Football Conference Youth League, 14 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

Chalfont St Peter FC
5 x fixtures dated 18 August, 21 August, 27 August, 1 September and 4 September
Southern League Division One Central
Five breaches of FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with automatic suspension

Daniel Hicks, Chalfont St Peter FC
5 x fixtures dated 18 August, 21 August, 27 August, 1 September and 4 September
Southern League Division One Central
Five breaches of FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with automatic suspension

Jamie Martin, Tooting & Mitcham United FC
Sittingbourne v Tooting & Mitcham United
Isthmian League Division One South, 17 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Dave Anderson, Harrow Borough FC
Lewes v Harrow Borough
Isthmian League Premier, 17 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

Tony Choules, Uxbridge FC
Burnham v Uxbridge
Southern League Central Division, 20 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Ross Standen, Whitehawk FC
Whitehawk v Kingstonian
Isthmian Premier League, 6 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Thursday 29 November

Danny Johnson, Ashton United FC
Twitter comments
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

Johnson has admitted the charge and requeted a non-personal hearing

Terry Boyle, Aldershot Town FC
AFC Wimbledon U19 v Aldershot Town U19
Youth Alliance Cup Group 5, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3 –  language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Boyle has denied the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Tommy Fraser, Whitehawk FC
Maidstone United v Whitehawk
FA Carlsberg Trophy, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Fraser has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Charlie Hill, Thatcham Town FC
Godalming Town v Thatcham Town
Southern League Central Division, 6 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

Hill has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Mark Nicholls, North Greenford United FC
Guildford City v North Greenford United
Southern League Central Division, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

No response received, processed as a denial and a non-personal hearing requested

Nathan Jackson, Romulus FC
Coalville Town v Romulus
Northern Premier League Division One South, 21 August 2012
FA Rule E3 – violent conduct

Jackson has denied the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Wednesday 28 November

Neil Warnock, Leeds United AFC
Millwall v Leeds United
Football League Championship, 18 November 2012
FA Rule E3  – improper conduct
Warnock admitted the charge but did not accept the standard penalty 1. Paper hearing requested

Warnock was given a £2,000 fine (standard penalty 1)

Tuesday 27 November

Nathan Doyle, Bradford City FC
Bristol Rovers FC v Bradford City FC
Football League 2, 24 November 2012
Dismissed for violent conduct
Claim received for wrongful dismissal

Claim upheld, three-match suspension withdrawn with immediate effect

Keith Southern, Huddersfield Town FC
Charlton Athletic FC v Huddersfield Town FC
Football League Championship, 24 November 2012
Dismissed for serious foul play
Claim received for wrongful dismissal

Claim dismissed, three-match suspension remains with immediate effect

Jaimie Carwardine, Taunton Town FC
Abingdon United v Taunton Town
Southern League South & West Division, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 –  language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Carwardine admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

James Dean, AFC Fylde
Kendal Town v AFC Fylde
Northern Premier League Premier Division, 27 August 2012
FA Rule E3 – violent conduct

Dean denied the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Dave Stringer, Rugby Town FC
Slough Town v Rugby Town
Southern League Central Division, 6 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

No response received, processed as a denial, non-personal hearing requested

James Gannon, Stockport County FC
Southend United v Stockport County
The FA Cup with Budweiser, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3 - language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct
Gannon denied the charge and requested a personal hearing

Charge proven. Gannon was given a one-match touchline ban and fined £450. The touchline ban has additional restrictions preventing Mr. Gannon from entering the changing rooms or the field of play 30 minutes prior to kick-off and for 30 minutes following the end of the match, which also includes half-time.

Mr. Gannon has requested written reasons and as such the sanction will not commence until he has either notified us that he does not wish to appeal, the period to appeal has expired or the outcome of any appeal is known

Click here for the full written reasons of the case

Monday 26 November

Steve Brown, Dover Athletic FC
Chelmsford City v Dover Athletic
The FA Trophy, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

Steve Peters, Cinderford Town FC
Bridgwater Town (1984) v Cinderford Town
Southern League South & West Division, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct; improper conduct

Joseph Whittington, Preston North End FC
Preston North End U18 v Accrington Stanley U18
Youth Alliance North West Conference, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with an automatic suspension

Preston North End FC
Preston North End U18 v Accrington Stanley U18
Youth Alliance North West Conference, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with an automatic suspension

Toby Blanche, Colchester United FC
Colchester United U18 v Queens Park Rangers U18
U18 Professional Development League 2, 27 October 2012
FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with an automatic suspension

Colchester United FC
Colchester United U18 v Queens Park Rangers U18
U18 Professional Development League 2, 27 October 2012
FA Rule E10 – failure to comply with an automatic suspension

Tuesday 20 November

Paul Lambert, Aston Villa FC
Manchester City v Aston Villa
Premier League, 17 November 2012
FA Rule E3 - language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Lambert admitted the charge, standard penalty 1 accepted (one match touchline ban to commence immediately and £8000 fine)

Paul Reid, Scunthorpe United FC
Scunthorpe United v Notts County
Football League 1, 17 November 2012
Dismissed for violent conduct
Claim made of wrongful dismissal

Claim dismissed, three-match suspension remains with immediate effect

Kieran Trippier, Burnley FC
Burnley v Charlton Athletic
Football League Championship, 17 November 2012
Dismissed for denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity
Claim made of wrongful dismissal

Claim dismissed, one-match suspension remains with immediate effect

Christophe Berra, Wolverhampton Wanderers FC
Watford v Wolverhampton Wanderers
Football League Championship, 17 November 2012
Dismissed for denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity
Claim made of wrongful dismissal

Claim upheld, one-match suspension removed with immediate effect

Jon Whitney, Walsall FC
Walsall v Swindon Town
Football League One, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 - use of abusive and/or insulting words towards a Match Official
Whitney denied the charge and requested a paper hearing

Charge proven, Independent Regulatory Commission ordered a two-match touchline ban and £1300 fine. This sanction will not come into effect until the period for Mr. Whitney to appeal has expired, he has notified us that he does not wish to appeal or the outcome of any such appeal is known

Click here for the full written reasons of the case

Thursday 15 November

Ashley Westwood, Portsmouth FC
Portsmouth v Notts County
The FA Cup, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3  – behaviour amounting to improper conduct
Westwood admitted the charge and requested a personal hearing

Westwood was warned as to his future conduct and fined £800

Tuesday 13 November

Alan Stubbs, Everton FC
Tranmere Rovers v Everton
Liverpool County FA Senior Cup Final, 1 August 2012
FA Rule E3 - use of abusive and/or insulting language
Stubbs admitted the charge and requested a personal hearing

Stubbs was given a two-match touchline ban from Everton FC Under-21s with immediate effect and fined £500.

Mr. Stubbs has requested written reasons for the decision so the sanction will not commence until either the period for appeal has expired, or Mr. Stubbs has confirmed in writing that he does not wish to appeal, or any appeal lodged by Mr. Stubbs against this decision is concluded

Jason Pearce, Leeds United AFC
Leeds United v Watford
Football League Championship, 10 November 2012
Dismissed for serious foul play
Claim received for wrongful dismissal

Claim dismissed, three match suspension remains with immediate effect

Jon Whitney, Walsall FC
Walsall v Swindon Town
Football League One, 10 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – use of abusive and/or insulting words towards a Match Official

Whitney has until 4pm on 16 November 2012 to respond to the charge

Kevin Milsom, Bridgwater Town FC
Bridgwater Town v Taunton Town
Southern League Cup, 1 November 2011
Two breaches of FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct; language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Milsom has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Danny Dafter, Brentwood Town FC
Potters Bar Town v Brentwood Town
Isthmian League Division One North, 9 October 2012
Two breaches of FA Rule E3 – use of abusive and/or insulting and/or threatening words and/or behaviour towards a Match Official; language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Dafter has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Mick Fogden, Worthing FC
Worthing v Whitstable Town
Isthmian league Division One South, 20 October 2012
Two breaches of FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct; improper conduct

No response received. Processed as a denial, non personal hearing requested

Scott Porter, Hythe Town FC
Maidstone United v Hythe Town
Isthmian League Division One South, 9 October 2012
FA Rule E3 - Language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Porter has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Mark Gee, North Leigh FC
Cinderford v North Leigh
Southern League South & West Division, 27 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – abusive and/or insulting words towards a Match Official

Gee has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Jemma Rose, Bristol Academy WFC
Twitter comments
FA Rule E3 - acted in a way which was improper and/or brought the game into disrepute in regard to a comment that was posted on Twitter.
Further alleged that this breach included a reference to a person or person’s disability within the meaning of FA Rule E3(2)
Rose admitted the charge and requested a paper hearing

Rose was warned as to her future conduct and fined £200

Monday 12 November

Barnsley FC
Huddersfield Town U18 v Barnsley U18
U18 Professional Development League 2, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative and/or violent behaviour

Huddersfield Town FC
Huddersfield Town U18 v Barnsley U18
U18 Professional Development League 2, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative behaviour

Tommy Warrilow, Tonbridge Angels FC
Tonbridge Angels v Bath City
Football Conference South, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Tonbridge Angels FC
Tonbridge Angels v Bath City
Football Conference South, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players conducted themselves in an orderly fashion

Friday 9 November

James Gannon, Stockport County FC
Southend United v Stockport County
The FA Cup, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3  – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Gannon has denied the charge and requested a personal hearing

Thursday 8 November

Kevin Rayner, Guildford City FC
Fleet Town v Guildford City
Southern League Central Division, 23 October 2012
Two breaches of FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct; improper conduct

Rayner has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Roly Martin, Guildford City FC
Guildford City v Leighton Town
Southern League Central Division, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Martin has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Leatherhead FC
Merstham v Leatherhead
Isthmian League Division One South, 6 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players conducted themselves in an orderly fashion

Leatherhead FC has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Gary Jones, Chester FC
Chester v Bradford Park Avenue
Football Conference North, 17 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Jones has denied the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Phil Thompson, Ossett Albion FC
Ossett Albion v Wakefield
Northern Premier League Division One North, 6 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Thompson has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Danny Cowley, Concord Rangers FC
Concord Rangers v Cray Wanderers
Isthmian Premier League, 20 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Cowley has admitted the charge and requested a non-personal hearing

Ryan Robbins, Coalville Town FC
Twitter Comments
FA Rule E3 – comments posted on twitter which were abusive and/or insulting and/or improper and/or brought the game into disrepute. Further alleged that this breach included a reference to a person or person’s disability within the meaning of FA Rule E3(2)

Darren Perrin, Frome Town FC
Frome Town v Hemel Hempstead Town
Southern League Premier Division, 3 November 2012
FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct

Wednesday 7 November

Mark Gee, North Leigh FC
Cinderford v North Leigh
Southern League South & West Division, 27 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – abusive and/or insulting words towards a Match Official

Leighton Town FC
Leighton Town v Thatcham Town
Southern League Central Division, 13 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players and/or officials conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative behaviour

Thatcham Town FC
Leighton Town v Thatcham Town
Southern League Central Division, 13 October 2012
FA Rule E20(a) – failure to ensure that its players and/or officials conducted themselves in an orderly fashion and/or refrained from provocative behaviour

Mick Martin, Worthing FC
Worthing v Whitstable Town
Isthmian League Division One South, 20 October 2012
Two breaches of FA Rule E3 – language and/or behaviour amounting to improper conduct; improper conduct

Jon Brady, Brackley Town FC
Worcester City v Brackley Town
Football Conference North, 29 October 2012
FA Rule E3 – improper conduct

 

Laws of the Game

Laws of
the game

Please make a selection below from the current laws of the game

Go